Eat Your Heart Out

Satisfy your sweet tooth by pre-ordering these heartfelt local sweets and treats for Valentine’s Day.

Lexi Bailey Baking
Featured on the cover of the November/December 2021 issue of Evansville Living, Lexi Bailey Baking is back with more irresistible homemade treats. Her Valentine’s Day box includes two red and pink funfetti cupcakes, two jumbo red velvet geode heart cake pops, and four chocolate-covered strawberries for $35. Orders will be available for pickup from 11 a.m.-1 p.m. Feb. 13.

Pie Pan Restaurant & Bakery
Don’t choose between sweets or flowers for your loved one. Get both from Pie Pan. Orders include a custom Valentine’s cake and a specially designed bouquet of flowers from Cottage Florist & Gifts. Call 812-425-2261 by Feb. 7 to order.

Go big or go home this Cupid’s Day. GaylaCake’s large dessert charcuterie package includes two hot chocolate bombs, four chocolate-covered strawberries, four chocolate-covered cherries, four chocolate-covered cheesecake bites, three mini chocolates, two chocolate suckers, three large cookies, three mini cookies, and eight meringues. The bakery has also partnered with Lefler Events to add a decorative balloon bundle, all for $65.

Not in the holiday mood? You can also choose an all-black balloon bundle and Anti-Valentine cookies for $43.19. All orders can be placed online.

Sweet Schmitt’s Candy
Add some action to your Valentine’s gift with breakable hearts from Sweet Schmitt’s. For $24.95, chocolate-molded hearts come pre-filled with your choice of wrapped caramels, marshmallows, truffles, and candy, plus a mallet to smash the chocolate heart to pieces. The shop is also offering 8-ounce shareable butter pecan clusters for $10 and vanilla caramel chocolate-covered hearts filled with 2 ounces of caramel for $5. Pre-orders for breakable hearts must be placed by Feb. 10.

Myriad Brewing Company
Lil’ Tate’s Cupcakes and Myriad Brewing Company have partnered to unveil four cupcake and 5-ounce beer pairings to be enjoyed in the tap room or at home. Combos include an oatmeal stout and apple pie cupcake with vanilla buttercream, a peach wheat and vanilla cupcake with buttercream and blueberry topping, a chocolate coconut porter and peanut butter cupcake with chocolate buttercream, or a strawberry graham cracker cream ale and a chocolate cupcake with buttercream. Orders are available for dine in ($24) and pick up ($30) on Feb. 10.

This Valentine’s Day, have “The Ultimate Sleepover” with Pangea’s $45 sweets box. Filled with two heart-shaped vanilla bean macarons, two chocolate passion fruit truffles, two red velvet cream cheese cookies, two chocolate-covered strawberries, and two strawberry cream cheese cupcakes, the box also comes with a breakfast of a brioche berry French toast bake for two and two hot chocolate sticks. Pre-order at 812-401-2404 by Feb. 8 and pick up on Feb. 12.

Jodi Keen
Jodi Keen
Jodi Keen is the managing editor of Evansville Living and Evansville Business magazines.

Related Articles

Latest Articles