Honey Moon Coffee Co.
4 locations in Evansville and Newburgh
Owners Zac and Jessica Parsons have quietly notched big victories since opening their first shop on South Weinbach Avenue nearly eight years ago. The brand, which acquired Evansville Coffee Co. in 2023, has earned accolades for its vanilla-and-lavender Purple Ace Latte (a nod to that first location near the University of Evansvilleโs campus), and Evansville Living readers regularly reward Honey Moonโs coffee with Best of Evansville awards. In an autumn kind of mood? The Sweater Weather, an espresso latte dressed up with peanut butter syrup, honey, and marshmallow cream, will make you think you’re at a bonfire.
River City Coffee + Goods
223 Main St.
This Downtown spot has been caffeinating Evansville and promoting city pride since 2016. Owner Heather Vaught โ named Best Evansville Brand Ambassador this year by Evansville Living editors โ offers specialty drinks including an 812 latte โif you like French toast, give this a try. Take your sips in the shopโs quiet back corner or out on the sidewalk.
Parlor Doughnuts
204 Main St. โข 301 N. Green River Road
As savory as Parlorโs flaky doughnuts are, donโt forget that the business first made its name in caffeine as Proper Coffee. Its doughnuts have taken off โ and launched a jaw-dropping 87 locations in five years. Evansville residents can sip their craft coffee in an upscale modern shop on the East Side or at Parlorโs headquarters in the Bitterman Building โ The location’s walnut-framed shelves and leather furniture resemble a traditional Viennese coffeehouse. Back to the brews: The rich, creamy Mayan Mocha pairs well with Parlorโs churro doughnut to celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month.
Mission Grounds
1107 Washington Square (inside the Evansville Rescue Mission Thrift Store at Washington Square Mall)
The Squirrly Latte is a must-try signature fall drink with a perfect balance of chocolate, caramel, amaretto, toffee nut, maple spice, and cinnamon. As you sip, wander over to the Thrift Store โ voted in 2024 by Evansville Living readers as the Best Thrift Store โ for gently used furniture, apparel, accessories, decor, and more. Purchases at Mission Grounds and the Thrift Store benefit Evansville Rescue Mission.
Penny Lane Coffeehouse
600 S.E. Second St. โข 601 E. Boonville New Harmony Road
As The Beatles sang in 1967, Penny Lane โis in my ears and in my eyes,โ and Evansvilleโs namesake coffeehouse similarly stimulates the senses. The shopโs casual, retro theme meshes perfectly with the Haynieโs Corner Arts District, and its classic rock-inspired lattes are a smash. The late John Lennon likely would approve of the Instant Karma, which features four espresso shots plus caramel.
Joe Brewski Coffee
10 N.W. Sixth St.
Nate Templeton and the team behind this coffee spot know their cold brew and keep a fun, jovial atmosphere at their Downtown Evansville shop. The salty-sweet Salted Caramel Cold Brew Latte is a menu staple, but donโt skip out on the Head Over Peels, a lightly banana-infused brew. (Does that count as a daily serving of fruit?)
Beans & Baristas
800 N. Green River Road (inside Eastland Mall)
On your next shopping excursion, follow the aroma of coffee to find Beans & Barista. The Dark Chocolate Decadence includes dark Belgium chocolate and Arabica coffee, perfect for chocolate lovers. Friendly staff also can help you choose from an array of coffee beans, loose tea, gifts, and seasonal decor.
Kite & Key Cafรฉ
2301 W. Franklin St.
Kite & Key Cafe is such a favorite of West Siders that the owners opened a coffee bar in 2023. Frothy cappuccinos, mochas, iced lattes, frappes, and more are on the menu at this chic, brick-walled shop. Need a pick-me-up? Order the Black Eye, a drip coffee featuring a double shot of espresso.
Scooterโs Coffee
535 E. Diamond Ave.
This drive-thru location is a quick, easy stop for coffee lovers on the go. Dubbed the chainโs signature drink, the Caramelicious includes a smooth caramel sauce and espresso with whipped cream drizzled with more caramel. Order it iced, hot, or blended. For a fall version, try a limited-edition Pumpkin Caramelicious.
Donut Bank
9 locations in Evansville, Newburgh, and Henderson, Kentucky
If youโre looking for a place to grab a morning drink with friends, you wonโt have a hard time finding a Donut Bank location to sit down. The family-owned business offers many syrups for customizing your cup of joe. We recommend a hot blueberry coffee, which boasts a fresh fruit pie taste with hints of cinnamon.
The Daily Grind
One S.E. Ninth St.
Open the thick metal exterior door at The Daily Grind, and the warm scent of coffee immediately wafts over you from the espresso machine. Even if you didnโt plan to order a cup of joe, odds are you leave with one. If youโre not counting calories, opt for a breve, which combines espresso and steamed half-and-half for a rich, fluffy version of an Italian latte. The Daily Grind takes coffee so seriously that general manager Cadey Hess travels overseas to study brewing techniques. Find that story in the November/December issue of Evansville Living.
Dunkin
5 locations in Evansville, Newburgh, and Henderson, Kentucky
The national chain knows its coffee. The butter pecan swirl with a layer of foam adds a dash of delectable flavor to your day. For an autumn kick, dip a Halloween Sprinkle munchkin into your frothy coffee drink.
The Newburgh Mercantile
224 W. Jennings St., Newburgh, Indiana
This shop exudes civic pride through local art and gifts, and its building is iconic, dating to 1867. Enjoy a matcha latte upstairs and marvel at the structureโs transformation from St. John the Baptist Church to Newburgh Country Store to The Newburgh Mercantile.
Black Lodge Coffee Roasters
610 Church St., New Harmony, Indiana
Imagine wrapping your hands around a steaming mug on a crisp autumn morning, lounging in a spacious environment with thick rugs and rustic decor. That experience awaits at Black Lodge Coffee Roasters, where you can build your own a latte โ for a fall day, we recommend a hot one with bourbon barrel stout โ before heading out to explore New Harmony.
Trickeyโs Brews and Bevs
120 W. Locust St., Boonville, Indiana
Trickeyโs quiet ambiance and beverage lineup is making waves beyond its home on the Boonville city square. The shop is approaching its third birthday and has rolled out an impressive lineup of fall drinks, including the hysterically named Oh My Gourd, a concoction of pumpkin and white chocolate syrup, espresso, steamed milk, and whipped cream with pumpkin drizzle and spice.
Roast Coffee Bar
136 Second St., Ste. 100, Henderson, Kentucky
When customers walk into Roast, they immediately feel welcomed by a colorful chalkboard decorated with a list of seasonal beverages. This season, try the S’mores or Pumpkin Patch latte. A bonus: Roastโs breakfast items and drink ingredients largely are sourced from local and small businesses.
Antler Specialty Goods
212 N. Main St., Henderson, Kentucky
Whether youโre working, gathering with friends, or having lunch, Antler is the spot to grab a coffee. Since 2022, patrons have been obsessed with drinks like the Sleepy Sailor, an oat milk latte featuring Wisconsin maple syrup and rum extract. Donโt limit yourself, though: The menu consistently evolves with unique and adventurous drinks.
Coffee+Cream
1646 Second St., Henderson, Kentucky
The team behind this spot, nestled in the Eastgate Shopping Center near U.S. 41, fosters a sense of togetherness and belonging for everyone. Enjoy any of their freshly brewed coffee accompanied with a long list of flavored creamers and syrups or the Tsunami, a scoop of ice cream with hot or iced coffee.
